Welcome to Up the creek cafe
Up the Creek Cafe, located in Wantage, NJ, is a hidden gem renowned for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional homemade cuisine. Patrons rave about the delightful pizza and calzones, which are crafted to perfection, alongside slow-cooked soups and popular garlic knots. The cafe's charm is amplified by its welcoming staff, creating an atmosphere reminiscent of true southern hospitality. With accolades like being voted best cheesecake four years running, it’s clear that Up the Creek Cafe is a destination worth seeking out. Whether you're on a bike ride or exploring nearby parks, this quaint spot promises a memorable culinary experience.
Up the creek cafe: Reviews & Ratings
Cute lil spot. Found this spot while riding my bike through the area. Stopped for a few slices. Pizza is pretty decent and the staff are very friendly. Place seems to have a some good specials and soups. Clean, cute, and courteous staff. This place was a pleasant surprise along my route.
What an off the path treasure find! My husband and I were traveling around Florida finished going to the caverns trying to look for a cute local spot to have some type of lunch at. He found this great location from Google reviews and pictures. From the moment we stepped in the southern hospitality and charm we felt welcomed. The food was cooked to order and fresh, the prices were reasonable and no short cuts. If you’re ever feeling lost and not knowing where to go just make sure you go up the creek and you’ll find your way home. Thank you to the staff for a wonderful visit and especially Miss Carol who made it even More special with conversation.
Beautiful place! The mushroom calzone and the pepperoni stromboli were exquisite! Loved the homemade style food and the wonderful atmosphere! The service is great as well! Voted as best cheesecake four years in a row too! Congrats!
Wow!! Stumbled across this place while looking for somewhere to eat lunch/dinner. We’re staying out at Tri State RV and wanted to grab food nearby while we explored High Point State Park and we are so thrilled we found you! Hands down the best pizza we’ve had in a very very long time. We’ve travelled through 31 states and this is a hidden gem. Congratulations on all your wins and we are excited to follow your journey and see your business continue to grow.
We stumbled upon this place on ride home from PA and were happy we did. The garlic knots were the best we ever had and the pizza was baked perfectly . Owners were very friendly- wish we lived closer so we could visit more often.
Kori was super hospitable from the second we came in. Being from NY you’re always skeptical about NJ pizza but theirs is some of the best we ever had , especially a fan of their artichoke pizza ! We also needed to try their award winning cheesecake, it did not disappoint! 10/10 recommend stopping here.
What a gem! Great home cooked food! My friends and I enjoyed our delicious breakfast that was prepared with all fresh products that was evident on the first bite!!! Don’t miss this best kept secret in Marianna, FL!
This is a little, 4-table young family-run pizzeria and restaurant. Atmosphere is fun and very friendly. The spirit of the place is what makes it great, and of course the food, not the decor. The ingredients and recipes are special. We had a veggie pizza. The crust was flavorful, a little flaky, and just-right crisp. It did not become soggy at all! The toppings were all very fresh and delicious, and generous. The sauce was on the mild side, but a fresh tomato flavor came through. Normally we would stop at a pizza. But this place claimed to have the prize for best cheesecake in NJ, so we had to try it. The cheese part was a light, almost airy, burst of flavor with a smooth, airy quality. Quite remarkable.The crust was a tasty (maybe a wee bit thick) graham cracker base. Very delicious in all. Plus, the owners and young server were all fun and interesting people. The experience overall was memorable in a good way, not just another pizzeria.
Location
-
1214 St 1214 NJ-23 Building B, Wantage, NJ 07461, United States Hotline: +1 973-702-1400
Welcome to Up the Creek Cafe, a hidden gem nestled in the charming town of Wantage, New Jersey. Located at 1214 NJ-23, Building B, this delightful eatery has quickly become a favorite among locals and travelers alike. With a phone number of +1 973-702-1400, this café is more than just a stop along your journey; it’s a welcoming retreat that epitomizes southern hospitality and charm.
Stepping inside Up the Creek Cafe, you are greeted by an atmosphere that feels both cozy and inviting. Reviews highlight the café’s cleanliness and the friendly demeanor of its staff, creating an experience that is as enjoyable as the food itself. The pièce de résistance? The culinary offerings, which range from delightful pizzas to scrumptious calzones, have captured the hearts and taste buds of many guests.
Take, for instance, the rave reviews on the pizza, often described as the best in many states. One recent visitor exclaimed that they found their best pizza in years here, while another was astonished by the exquisite flavors of the mushroom calzone and pepperoni stromboli. These aren’t just meals; they’re experiences, crafted with care and attention to detail. The café’s special offerings, including homemade soups and garlic knots, are also frequently praised, adding layers of flavor and satisfaction to the menu.
It's not just about the food at Up the Creek Cafe; it's about the kind of service that makes you feel at home. Numerous patrons have shared stories of the warm conversations they enjoyed with staff members like Miss Carol, enhancing their visits and creating memorable moments. This engaging community atmosphere, combined with freshly cooked meals, ensures that every visit is special and personal.
Whether you're biking through the area or simply seeking a cozy spot for a meal, Up the Creek Cafe is an assurance of good eats and great hospitality. If you find yourself lost and in need of a tasty refuge, just remember: “go up the creek and you’ll find your way home.”
With accolades like being voted the best cheesecake for four consecutive years, it is evident that Up the Creek Cafe is not just about a quick bite; it’s about delicious food, community spirit, and creating cherished memories. Don’t miss out on this delightful café that promises to surprise and satisfy!